Prequel | Part One | Part Two

Then
Now (what a dramatic change!)

It’s been a journey, folks, but I made it and I feel… relieved, which is a kind of good, isn’t it?

Last time, I had just ordered yarn to finish my second sleeve. Alas, the dye lot was different (naturally, after five years), and while G insisted it wasn’t noticeable, I very much noticed it. The new shade is more brick red and, while I accept it was close, I think it would have looked very much like I’d run out of yarn and had to use a different colour to finish. Which, to be fair, would have been absolutely accurate.

Can you see the difference in the two red shades?

So I went to Plan B, which was to make a feature of the sleeve being different. I had all sorts of DK cotton in my stash, certainly enough to make a rainbow sleeve, so that’s where I went. It’s ended up being by far my favourite part of the jumper!

After I finished the sleeve and tried it on, I wasn’t happy with the neckline. It was too wide and not a neat finish. It’s possible that the pattern called for a neckline to be added but given that I’ve lost it, who could say? If you haven’t read the other posts, I found this half finished sweater in my stash along with some of the yarn I needed to finish (the rest of the yarn had been scavenged for other projects) and no pattern. Not knowing what I was “supposed” to do gave me free rein to do whatever I wanted and I thought, why not more rainbow?

I struggle with picking up stitches, and with seaming. This project made me practise those skills and I have to say I really think I’ve done the absolute best I could. Certainly the picked up stitches at the neckline are the best I’ve ever done and that was satisfying, even if it’s not perfect.

Side seam before blocking
Side seam after blocking
Sleeve seam before blocking
Sleeve seam after blocking

Straight off the needles the body of the jumper was keen to skrunkle up tight. The yarn label said ‘do not soak’. Spoiler: I soaked. Just for a wee half hour with some conditioner, followed by a drain and spin in the machine alongside a clean towel. I then pinned, then steamed and pressed the seams. The end result is… fine? Certainly flatter and wider, though I guess I picked up too many of those side stitches as it’s v curved round the hem.

At the end of the day, it’s done and out of stash. I’m concerned that it’s not of high enough quality to donate anywhere, though, and I don’t think I’ll wear it. It’s very fitted on me, in a way that isn’t super comfortable. Also I think I really just don’t enjoy cotton garments for myself.

What would you do?


24 responses to “Mysterious Sweater – It is Done”

  1. Cosmicknitter-ReginaMary Avatar

    Wow! Good for you, and what a transformation! Love how you navigated the sleeve.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you! It certainly was a big change from the last post where it hardly looked like a garment at all.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. adg34 Avatar

    I love it! The rainbow additions were an excellent choice!
    I often hang on to these items until I find someone who might really appreciate it. Then randomly gift it to them. ๐Ÿ˜„

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I do have one friend in mind who may like it – and thank you for your kind words!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Kat Avatar

    Okay… I LOVE what you did with that sleeve! It is brilliant! (and I bet that someone would LOVE this sweater if they found it at a thrift shop!) I would give this proudly!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you Kat, you always seem to know just what to say!

      Like

  4. Laura Kate Avatar

    I’d like to respond to your concern about the quality of your sweater, and whether is it good enough to be donated. I second Kat’s opinion. In my experience, most commercially made garments that are donated to thrift stores have much lower quality than this piece.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Oh that’s so kind of you Laura, thank you! I do struggle not to see every imperfection or oddity in the things I make. I really appreciate you taking the time to offer a more positive view.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Anita Avatar

    The sleeve is so cheery, and I love it!! I like that the neck is colorful too.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I also really like those parts ๐Ÿ˜Š

      Liked by 1 person

  6. quiteayarnblog Avatar

    It is a great finish! You did a wonderful job with completing something from your stash with no pattern, and you did it with style :) Someone is going to just love this – you’ll see!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you so much, this really helps me feel differently about it!

      Like

  7. nanacathy2 Avatar

    First hats off to you for the ingenious sleeve and neckband. If you really won’t wear it, then donate it. It might look very Good under a pinafore dress or dungarees.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Ooh that would be a cute look! Thank you Cathy.

      Like

  8. knittingissofun Avatar

    What a fun sweater!! I’m amazed you were able to pick up a project and finish it after sitting so long. I’m sure someone will adore it.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Aw thank you, I do hope so!

      Liked by 1 person

  9. randomlyerin Avatar

    It really did turn out very pretty! If I hadn’t been following your posts about it I would have assumed that this was the design all along. Since you don’t like the way it fits, maybe ask around and see if one of your friends or family members would like it?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. CA Avatar

      I offered it to one friend but the fit wasn’t quite right. I’m thinking now maybe a friend’s kid…

      Like

  10. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

    The arm with the stripes is a brilliant add – sorry you will not be wearing it per your post. Perhaps you should donate it and how do you know it isn’t perfect for someone else :-)

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I think you’re all right and it’ll be perfect for someone – going to offer it to a friend this weekend and if not, in the donations pile it goes. You’ve all been so kind to encourage me to see the goodness in this creation ๐Ÿ˜Š

      Liked by 1 person

      1. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

        That is awesome :-)
        You are so crazy talented, love seeing your creations in the blogosphere!

        Like

      2. CA Avatar

        Oh that’s so kind of you Tierney! Thank you so much!

        Liked by 1 person

  11. quietwatercraft Avatar

    I can definitely spot the difference between the original yarn and the new stuff, so the rainbow sleeve was a good call. Also it looks great!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Validation! Thank you – I could definitely see it, too.

      Like

Leave a reply to quietwatercraft Cancel reply