I found a half-knitted sweater while I was cataloguing my stash. I decided to pick it back up and finish it off – but I’ll be honest, I’m having doubts.

I can see why I packed it in to begin with: I’m not enjoying the yarn at all. It’s splitty, and not soft on my hands. It’ll probably soften when washed but that doesn’t help me now!

On the other hand, the evidence for the prosecution (ie the voice saying ‘finish this project’) is fairly compelling. First of all, when I un-did the side seam, the yarn was unusable afterwards. Not to say that frogging would cause the same problems… but it might. It split into strands which got caught up in each other, and felt generally frayed and impractical even for seaming by the time it was done.

The side seam didn’t like being unravelled and turned against me, splitting and knotting and snarling up

Secondly, I actually might have enough yarn to finish. I’ve done some sums based on the rows I’ve knitted and it looks like the 91g I have remaining might just do it. So it wouldn’t cost any money, just time.

Speaking of time, the long side rows are 10 minutes a go – and I’ve done eight of them already. There are another 17 to go, then most of it is bound off and just the sleeve remains, which decreases rapidly at the shoulder. So let’s say (*total guess alert*) three hours on the side panel, then another three on the sleeve . What’s six hours in the scheme of things?

The colour really isn’t this vibrantly pink in real life

I’ve gone to the trouble of taking out the seam to lay it flat and take measurements, and then started the actual knitting – so quitting now doesn’t seem right.

I *have* heard of the sunk cost fallacy, now that you mention it…

The sleeve looks humongous when it’s laid out flat!

The bottom line is that the jury may be out, but they’re knitting while they think about it.

I’ve added this post to the Unraveled Wednesday linkup, with thanks to Kat for hosting.


17 responses to “WiP Wednesday: Mysterious Sweater Restarted”

  1. Claire Avatar

    We’ve all had a project like this, my concern would be washing it. Do you think the yarn will hold up in the wash ? You can always donate it if you’re not going to wear it.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I think it’ll be OK once it’s knitted up – I’ll be raging if not! And that’s what I think too, better a finished garment that goes to someone who’ll wear it than sitting gathering dust.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Kat Avatar

    Splitty yarn is the friend of no knitter… sorry about that! (and add hard on your hands to the mix… oy!) This sweater is the true test of Knitter Grit and Determination!

    I hope that you can get back to that delightful Sea Glass sweater and soon!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Wait till you see my Sea Glass, Kat, I’m so pleased with it!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Cosmicknitter-ReginaMary Avatar

    I don’t know what I would do if I were in your shoes. On the one hand, you have done so much work already. On the other hand, if you really loved the sweater, you might not have put it aside in the first place. Do you remember why you stopped knitting on it in the first place?

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I remember very little about it, which is odd because I generally have a very good memory! But I don’t want to put it back aside so it’s finish or throw out and that seems such a waste.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Cosmicknitter-ReginaMary Avatar

        This happened to me once. I was knitting a large cabled throw. It took me 3 years to complete because I would put it aside and forget about it especially in the warmer months. Well, when I finally finished it, it was shaped like a trapezoid because my tension improved so much over the year!

        Like

      2. CA Avatar

        😅 I’ve made plenty of trapezoid blankets and even scarves! It’s a good argument for never putting a project in time out… but sometimes they deserve it.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Anita Avatar

    Looks like I was going to echo Claire’s sentiments. I was wondering if a wash test with a swatch would be better if you had enough yarn to spare, but you obviously don’t, by the looks of it. You’re right though, better a usable finished project from the six hours that remain!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. CA Avatar

      I’m on a countdown! And I can balance with other fun projects (one at a time though or it’ll just end up put back in stash again!)

      Liked by 1 person

  5. knittingissofun Avatar

    Fingers crossed it all works out and you love the finished sweater.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you! Time is showing that I was really quite wrong with my maths… but I’m going to finish the side panel and see where I am then.

      Like

  6. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

    “jury may be out, but they’re knitting while they think about it.” – thanks for the laugh!
    It will be fun to see how this sweater comes out and congrats for taking it on!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      😁 You’re welcome!

      Like

  7. quiteayarnblog Avatar

    I really hope that it works out and you can finish and love it once it’s done!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you – just a sleeve to go now!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Cosmicknitter-ReginaMary Cancel reply