A friend of mine who very gratifyingly believes I’m capable of making anything asked me if I’d recreate a jumper she’d seen online for her. It was described in the listing as ‘crochet crop jumper’. I looked at it briefly and said, brimming with confidence, ‘Sure!’.

Photo from Next.co.uk

How naive I was, to believe the description. I thought ‘Crochet? No bother. It’ll be HDCs all the way, for sure’. I bought lovely soft yarn in a nice cream shade, picked up a pattern that was similarly shaped to get sizes from, and started on a ribbed collar one afternoon in a nice pub in London. I had the whole day to myself and this seemed a great way to spend it.

It was while making the collar that I zoomed in to the original photo for comparison. Reader: this collar was not crochet. It was very clearly knitted. Alarm bells should have sounded there and then, but I continued blithely on, thinking… I don’t know what. That the collar was knitted but the rest crocheted? Not impossible, but equally not exactly scalable for mass production. Still, I pressed ahead and finished up the collar, then started grappling with how best to make increases for shoulders.

HDCs balanced on my knee

It was around the fourth row that it dawned on me that my HDCs didn’t look like the jumper I was trying to recreate. The holes in that jumper are triangular, but I had regular squares all the way. So I zoomed in on the stitches, and confronted then properly for the first time. I was looking at knitting! What flavour of knitting, I had no idea, but those were unmistakably knit stitches.

Zoomed in section from photo on
Next.co uk

Sugar.

So since then – about a month – I’ve been periodically thinking it over, zooming in to the picture some more, Googling, and asking for help here on my blog. I tried a few stitch combination swatches and unravelled them in a huff. I tried slipping, increases and decreases, yos, dropped stitches… None of it looked right and, more to the point, none of it felt like a pattern I’d be able to easily knit up.

I went back and had another search, but this time looking in Ravelry for any adult sweater in sport weight with 4.5 or 5mm needles (at least I’d figured out what needle size I wanted). And there I found The Ivy Sweater (Ravelry link) by NEA Knitwear (Designer’s site). The Ivy has rows of twisted rib that looked something like the effect I wanted! If I could just throw in a row with yarn overs that should do the trick.

Photo from NEA Knitwear

It’s ideal to have sizing and shaping instructions to work to, and while it’s a more oversize fit than the original target, one must be flexible, especially when one has been trying to figure out a pattern for a month. Here’s where I got to – my tension was woefully wobbly, I missed a row of purls, there were already two dropped stitches, and do those yos seem a bit gapey? I’ve unravelled it. The project continues…

I’ve added this post to the Unraveled Wednesday linkup, with thanks to Kat for hosting!


18 responses to “WiP Wednesday: Fauxchet Jumper – Reverse Engineering”

  1. lisaviolinviola Avatar

    Your swatch is getting pretty close to looking like the original! I would have guessed twisted rib/mock cables as well. When I first looked at the original, I wondered if it was a stitch best achieved on a knitting machine. Some of them are on the mass-produced sweaters. But, after seeing your swatch, it looks like it’s just a matter of getting the dropped stitches established, which you’re probably on the verge of.

    Like

  2. Laura Kate Avatar

    Hm, you have a challenge, no question. But you also have gumption and the skills to meet it.

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      This is so kind of you, thank you!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Kat Avatar

    I am in awe of your skills and determination! I also am loving the natural white sweater! Hmm, I don’t have one of those … perhaps I need one!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Aw thank you so much! The natural colour is lovely, not my bag but nice to work with.

      Like

  4. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

    That swatch was quite impressive as is your attempt to reverse engineer that lovely sweater – wow! Your friend is lucky!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you! She is very appreciative and patient, too, luckily.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Anita Avatar

    Your swatch looks pretty good! One more twist should do it, I think. Your dedication to figuring this out is pretty admirable–go you! We’re cheering you on. :-)

    On the other hand, it’s funny how knitting and crochet have been used interchangeably everywhere. Especially in visual media–someone is working on some beautiful, crocheted granny squares… using knitting needles, lol! ;-)

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you for the vote of confidence, it really helps!

      It’s so funny how crochet is having a moment but a lot of it is knitwear in disguise 😁

      Liked by 1 person

  6. kmkat Avatar

    What a friend you are! Those last two photos look spot-on. Also, I hesitate to tell you this, but no one in the history of crochet has been able to invent a commercially viable machine that can crochet. If something is crocheted, it was made by a person. https://littleworldofwhimsy.com/are-there-crochet-machines-i-asked-an-expert/

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Oh that’s cool! I had no idea 😁

      Like

  7. kiki Avatar
    kiki

    The saga of the mystery stitch continues, I see. Drat… I really thought you’d cracked the case. I shall continue the research.
    YOU CAN DO IT! 👏🙌🎉

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      I’ve accepted it won’t be identical and have another couple of things to try before I just pick one and go with it!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. kiki Avatar
        kiki

        OK, well that’s a little less pressure on you. It’s going to be a lovely jumper anyway and I’m looking forward to seeing how it goes.

        Liked by 1 person

  8. nanacathy2 Avatar

    You are an amazing friend for sure. I hope your effort is truly appreciated.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you Cathy – it really is, my pal is very knit worthy.

      Like

  9. quiteayarnblog Avatar

    You are a really great friend! Your swatch is looking a lot like the original – you can do this!

    Like

    1. CA Avatar

      Thank you so much, it really is helpful! My experiments have taken me further away from the result I want, I think, so I need to just make a choice and proceed!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to quiteayarnblog Cancel reply